Elliott said the USA business does not provide "meaningful diversification" to BHP as a whole and there are no synergies between the US business and the company's mining assets.
"Despite the first-class quality of most of BHP's assets, BHP as an investment has underperformed", Elliott, which manages about $33 billion, said in the letter to the company's board.
Activist shareholder Elliott Advisors on Monday proposed BHP Billiton scrap its dual-company structure in favour of a primary listing in London and a secondary listing in Sydney. The firm said it holds an approximately 4.1% stake in the resources major's London-listed shares.
Elliott said its plan could increase shareholder value by up to 48.6 percent for holders of BHP's Sydney shares and 51 percent for London shareholders.
"If Elliott gets its way and BHP's share price rises as a result, we would not be surprised to see its 4.1% interest disposed of in short order, leaving the company and other shareholders to pick up the pieces".
Elliott's demerger proposal is based on a view that investors would ascribe a higher value for these assets in a separately listed entity, says BHP.
BHP would also demerge its US petroleum assets into an entity to be listed on the New York Stock Exchange and commit to returning excess cash to shareholders.
BHP said it's been in talks with the hedge fund for many months, and the costs and risks associated with the proposals outweigh the benefits. Hedge funds and other institutional investors own 3.89% of the company's stock.
"The goal is to provide details of the BHP shareholder value unlock plan to all of BHP's shareholders, so that BHP can engage openly with all parties on the plan to unlock shareholder value", Elliott said in the letter.
As you might already be aware, BHP Billiton operates as a dual-listed structure.
"We have laid the foundations for the group to substantially grow the base value of its operations", BHP said in its statement. The average 1 year price objective among brokerages that have issued a report on the stock in the last year is GBX 1,284.10 ($15.95).
"We see the demerger of BHP's Gulf of Mexico assets in combination with the USA onshore petroleum assets as providing a standalone USA petroleum business with consistent cash flow to fund its own further expansion, allowing BHP to increase its focus on its core competencies and also helping the value of BHP's remaining core portfolio to positively re-rate". It pointed to returns of $23 billion in share buybacks, and dividends of $56 billion since the mine operator's dual-listed structure was formed in 2001.
The investment firm is also arguing BHP could buy back shares effectively at a 14% discount by making better use of about $9.7 billion accumulated franking credits, which offset taxes on Australian stock dividends. The Company is a producer of various commodities, including iron ore, metallurgical coal, copper and uranium.
'The whole idea of an oil spin-off or de-merger has been around for as long as BHP's had petroleum'. The Iron Ore segment is engaged in mining of iron ore.
The airline issued an apology over the incident and said it would refund the ticket costs of all passengers on Sunday's flight. After what happened, Dao "has no interest in ever seeing an airplane" and will probably be driven to Kentucky, Demetrio said.
However, the International Monetary Fund said these economies could still manage through the weaker growth by strengthening their institutional frameworks, protecting trade integration, permitting exchange rate flexibility and containing vulnerabilities from high current account deficits and large public debts.
Sevilla got a goal in the first minute by Stevan Jovetic, and overcame a double by Gael Kakuta, to end a six-game winless streak. Zidane has seen speculation mount his position could be under scrutiny should Real fail to go on to deliver the La Liga title.
An insider at Disney told The Sun , 'Harry was one of the early names in contention when the studio looked at Han Solo . However, Harry is performing well on downloads, now outrunning Shape Of You by 3:1.
His confidence is not without substance, as James has ran the Eastern Conference this decade, including six straight Finals. Although he fouled out in overtime, power forward James Johnson had 16 points and a team-high nine assists in 36 minutes.
Five driving modes are available in the 2018 Trackhawk which split the torque transfer between the front and rear axles. Nappa leather and suede seats are embroidered with "Trackhawk" logos with option to both heat and ventilate.
Splatoon and ARMS are both titles Nintendo users are looking forward too, especially as everyone has started to finish up Zelda. Nearly every first-party title that Nintendo puts out has had amiibo support, so this isn't entirely out of the question.
In a tweet after a meeting of NDA leaders in New Delhi yesterday, Mr Modi said, the work on the NDA's expansion will continue. The meeting started with a welcome address by BJP chief Amit Shah and concluded with Modi's speech.
Sherman is a four-time Pro Bowler and a three-time first-team All-Pro, and he's been terrific during his six seasons in Seattle. For weeks, Richard Sherman has publicly wanted out of the Seattle Seahawks organization, according to ESPN's Adam Schefter .
5 dead in Venezuela protests as movement gains steam
State officials have tweeted images and videos of demonstrators vandalising public property and throwing rocks at police. The next major organised rallies called by opposition leaders are set for Wednesday next week.
Taiwan bans consumption of dog, cat meat
Each year, the festival attracts the wrath of animal rights activists who call the practice of slaughtering dogs inhumane. More than 800 dogs also have been rescued from animal farms in South Korea, according to Humane Society International .
Microsoft Finally Puts A Bullet In Windows Vista, Today
Today is the final day for Windows Vista extended support , which means that the divisive operating system is well and truly dead. Your choices for moving to Windows 10 are simple, either buy a license for it (to retain your PC) or buy a new PC altogether.
Troops kill militant blamed for beheadings of Canadians in 2016
Be proactive - Use the "Flag as Inappropriate" link at the upper right corner of each comment to let us know of abusive posts. The militants are still holding at least 29 captives in Sulu's jungles, many of them foreign tugboat and cargo ship crewmen.
Merkel to Trump: push forward UN Syria process
Obama visited Germany six times as president, but he captured the hearts and minds of Germans before he was even elected. The appearance is expected to be Obama's first public talk since leaving office in January.
Blue Jays 3B Donaldson departs with calf injury
Now in addition to the quiet bats, there is some concern with Donaldson who pulled up with a sore calf on Sunday in Tampa. Marco Estrada took his first loss of the season giving up 5 earned runs on 7 hits while striking out 5 over 5 innings.
Sad that Sindh is not a part of India: LK Advani
The PM reportedly offered prayers for the prosperity and harmony of her country, and for strong bilateral ties with India. Mamata's opposition to water share appears to be the biggest stumbling block to reaching an agreement on the Teesta River.